All guides

US versionOther versions: France (in French) · Belgium (in French) · Switzerland (in French) · England

Moving

Hire movers or rent a truck: which is right for your move?

Cheaper isn't always cheaper. Compare the whole move, not just the price.

The answer in 2 lines. Movers cost more, but they carry the load and are responsible for your belongings, up to the level of protection on your contract. A rental truck costs less, but everything is on you: driving, loading, damage and injuries. The right choice depends on how much you own, the distance, stairs, and how much help you really have. For a move across state lines, always check the mover's USDOT number with FMCSA before you sign.

The 3 steps

  1. Make a room-by-room inventory, and note stairs, elevators, distance and heavy items.
  2. Get several written estimates from movers, based on someone actually seeing your belongings, and compare them with the full cost of a truck (rental, mileage, fuel, gear, insurance).
  3. Be honest about how much help you'll have on moving day, and what your own time is worth.

Comparing the two options

What to compareProfessional moversRental truck
PriceHigher; depends on weight or volume, distance, services and the dateLower; depends on truck size, days and miles
Damage and lossThe mover is liable, at the protection level you choose on the contractOn you; check what your own insurance covers
DrivingThe crew drivesYou drive a large vehicle: ask the rental office what license it requires
Effort and injuriesThe crew carriesYou and your helpers carry: watch your backs
PaperworkWritten estimate, bill of lading, inventoryRental contract, condition check at pickup and return, parking

Hiring movers: what to check

  • Moving to another state: the mover must be registered with the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) and have a USDOT number. Look it up with the search tool on FMCSA's Steps to Select a Mover page: type the company name or USDOT number to see its registration and complaint history.
  • Before an interstate move, movers and brokers must give you the booklet Your Rights and Responsibilities When You Move (PDF). Read the sections on estimates and valuation.
  • Protection level: by default, FMCSA describes "Full Value Protection," where the mover answers for the replacement value of lost or damaged items. If you sign for "Released Value," coverage is only 60 cents per pound per item. List high-value items on the paperwork. Details are on FMCSA's Liability & Protection page.
  • Moving within one state: federal rules don't apply. Each state sets its own rules (some license movers, some don't). Check with your state attorney general or consumer protection office.

What not to do

  • A quote over the phone or online with nobody looking at your belongings: FMCSA lists this as a red flag.
  • A mover who demands cash or a large deposit before the move, or asks you to sign documents with blanks.
  • A crew that shows up in an unmarked rental truck, or a company with no local address and no USDOT number for an interstate move.
  • Overloading a rental truck, or forgetting its height under bridges, parking garages and drive-throughs.

If you rent a truck

  • Walk around the truck before you leave and take photos of every scratch and dent. Do the same when you return it.
  • Read what the rental contract's damage waiver covers, and the deductible. The FTC advises checking whether your own auto insurance or credit card already covers you before you buy rental coverage. Call your insurer and card issuer, and ask specifically about a moving truck: coverage for cars doesn't always apply to trucks.
  • Some cities require a permit to park a moving truck on the street. Check your city's website or call 311 where available.
  • Rent a hand truck, straps and moving blankets. Lift with your legs, and carry heavy furniture with two people.

Good to know

  • There are in-between options: movers for the heavy pieces only, or a loading crew without a truck.
  • Some companies are brokers who hand your move to another company. Ask who will actually do the move, and check that company's USDOT number too.
  • Prices are often higher in summer and at the end of the month. If you can, pick a weekday in the middle of the month.

In the United States

  • For interstate moves, FMCSA says that with a non-binding estimate, the mover can't require you to pay more than 110 percent of the estimate at delivery. Get the estimate in writing and signed.
  • FMCSA can't settle a damage claim for you. File your written claim with the mover, within nine months of delivery.
  • Problem with an interstate mover (deception, goods held hostage, no registration)? File a complaint online with the FMCSA Complaint Center, or call 1-888-368-7238 (1-888-DOT-SAFT). Have the company's name, USDOT number, your estimate and bill of lading ready.

In Atlanta, Marcus is moving a one-bedroom on the third floor, no elevator, 15 miles across town. He rents a truck, books three friends, and photographs the truck at pickup. For his upright piano alone, he hires a moving crew and gets a written estimate first.

A made-up story, for illustration.

Bobby

Read more guides

Bobby publishes free practical guides written for the United States: American laws, numbers and organizations. In the United States, Bobby answers your questions; it does not put you in touch with professionals.

All guides: United States

Sources, verification, confidence

Verified on November 14, 2026, for the United States. Confidence: high for the federal rules on interstate moves (registration, red flags, valuation, claims); medium for moves within one state, where rules vary; prices vary too much to be quoted.

Related guides

Also worth reading