US versionOther versions: France (in French) · Belgium (in French) · Switzerland (in French)
Home insurance
You disagree with the insurance adjuster: what can you do?
The adjuster's estimate is a starting point, not the final word.
The answer in 2 lines. The adjuster your insurer sends works for the insurer, and their estimate can be challenged. If you disagree, dispute it in writing with your evidence before you accept any payment as final. If the disagreement is about how much the loss is worth, your policy probably has an appraisal clause. You can also hire a licensed public adjuster (you pay their fee) or a lawyer. Your state insurance department takes complaints for free. The rules vary by state.
The 4 steps
- Ask for the adjuster's estimate in writing, with the line-by-line detail, if you don't have it yet.
- List exactly what you dispute: the cause, the amount, depreciation, missing items, repair prices.
- Write to your insurer with your evidence (photos, receipts, written estimates from licensed contractors). Keep copies and a log of every call.
- Read your policy: look for the "Appraisal" section and any deadline to sue the insurer.
Your options, from simplest to heaviest
| Step | How it works | Who pays |
|---|---|---|
| Written dispute | You send your arguments and evidence to the insurer and ask for a review | Free |
| Appraisal | Each side picks an appraiser; the two pick an umpire. Usually limited to the amount of the loss | Under standard wording, you pay your appraiser and half of the umpire and shared costs |
| Public adjuster | A state-licensed adjuster who works for you and negotiates with the insurer | You, often as a percentage of the payment; caps vary by state |
| State insurance department complaint | The department can look into a claim that is unfairly delayed or denied | Free |
| Lawyer and court | For serious disputes, especially over coverage | You, as agreed with the lawyer |
Appraisal: what it can and can't settle
- Amount, not coverage: the Texas Department of Insurance explains that appraisal is for disputes about how much your claim is worth, not whether your policy covers the loss. New York's regulator notes that appraisal can't be used for disputes over the cause of the damage.
- How it works: you and the insurer each choose an appraiser, and the two appraisers choose an umpire. An agreement signed by two of the three usually sets the amount.
- Check the wording: how to request appraisal, the time limits and whether the result is binding depend on your policy and your state's law.
What not to do
- Cashing a check or signing a release labeled "final" before reading it: ask the insurer in writing whether you can still dispute the rest.
- Throwing away damaged items or finishing repairs before the dispute is settled. Take photos and keep samples, but still prevent further damage.
- Signing a public adjuster contract on the spot after a disaster: check the license, the fee and how to cancel first.
- Waiting too long: your policy and your state's law set deadlines to sue the insurer.
Choosing a public adjuster
- Check the license with your state insurance department. Texas, for example, licenses public adjusters through TDI.
- Get the fee in writing. Caps vary: in Texas, the fee can be up to 10% of what the insurer pays; in New York, it can't be more than 12.5% of the recovery. California says no fee should be charged on payments you got before the contract was signed.
- Know how to cancel: Texas gives you 72 hours after signing. California also gives you a short period to cancel, but its public adjuster rules can change, so ask the Department of Insurance for the current deadline. Florida says the contract must state the cost of services.
- No guarantees: Florida warns that a public adjuster can't promise a faster or larger settlement. For a small claim, a well-documented written dispute is often enough.
In your state
- Texas: What if my insurance isn't paying enough? and what to know before hiring a public adjuster.
- New York: DFS explains adjusters, appraisers and umpires.
- Florida: the Insurance Consumer Advocate's public adjuster tips (PDF).
- California: the Department of Insurance offers voluntary mediation of disputed homeowners claims during a declared state of emergency (Residential Insurance guide). Hotline: 800-927-4357.
- Any state: use the NAIC directory to find your department, then its complaint form (online, by mail or by phone in most states). Include your policy and claim numbers, your communication log and the outcome you want (NAIC: How to File a Complaint).
Good to know
- You can be there when the adjuster inspects, and you can bring someone to help you.
- If the cause of the damage is what's disputed, see How to prove the origin of a water leak.
- For complaints and mediation in general, see Disagree with your home insurer? Complaints and mediation.
After a kitchen fire in San Antonio, the adjuster's estimate for Marcus covers only the upper cabinets. Marcus disputes it in writing with photos and two licensed contractors' estimates. When the insurer won't budge on the amount, he requests appraisal under his policy. His appraiser and the insurer's agree to add the countertop and range hood without needing the umpire.
A made-up story, for illustration.
Read more guides
Bobby publishes free practical guides written for the United States: American laws, numbers and organizations. In the United States, Bobby answers your questions; it does not put you in touch with professionals.
All guides: United StatesSources, verification, confidence
Verified on November 14, 2026, for the United States. Confidence: high for the steps (written dispute, appraisal, public adjuster, complaint); medium for state fee caps and cancellation periods, which can change. Deadlines to sue depend on your policy and state law. Your policy sets your coverage, deductibles and limits. Bobby doesn't recommend any insurer, adjuster or policy.
- Texas Department of Insurance — What if my insurance isn't paying enough?
- Texas Department of Insurance — Public adjusters: What to know before you hire one
- New York Department of Financial Services — Adjusters, Appraisers & Umpires
- Florida Insurance Consumer Advocate — Working With A Public Adjuster: Your Consumer Rights
- California Department of Insurance — Don't Get Scammed After a Disaster
- California Department of Insurance — Residential Insurance: Homeowners and Renters
- NAIC — How to File a Complaint
- NAIC — Insurance Departments